cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
brixter
Making moves
Status: In development

In Firefox Android, when you maximize a video player , the text "Entering full screen mode" appears. It stays there for a few seconds and blocks the video controls and subtitles. I see no purpose for this popup message because it is obvious that the video player is maximized. Please remove it.

13 Comments
Status changed to: New idea
Jon
Community Manager
Community Manager

Thanks for submitting an idea to the Mozilla Connect community! Your idea is now open to votes (aka kudos) and comments.

FlameStoat
Strollin' around

At first I disagreed because I thought "well, the user needs to be alerted to things taking over fullscreen".

But then I realised there's no confirmation dialog, it's just a passive alert, so if the user really didn't want fullscreen it would be too late anyways.

And, a dialog would be too obstructive, so basically the best solution is to skip it altogether.

varric
New member

Therre should be some config option to enable/disable this popup on firefox mobile.

Shahrokh-sh2118
New member

Hi. Thanks. My mobaile is a Android10 Ram128 Memory4

panaceus
New member

This is a dreadful UI choice.  You must at least have an option to toggle this off.  I created an account just to leave this comment.

TopAce6
New member

Completely agree, it's very annoying and completely useless.

 

it blocks subtitles, and controls, have to rewind every single time i enter full screen to see what I've missed in the sub titles.

MK2
Strollin' around

I agree that there should be an option to disable this entirely. I don't need a message telling me when Firefox goes into fullscreen mode, because as a human being, I have these things called eyeballs and they have the amazing ability of letting me know that Firefox went into fullscreen mode, because I can see the title bar and the Android controls disappear. Shocking I know - apparently very few of us actually have this ability - but for those of us who do, it renders this prompt as utterly useless and invasive.

But since the Firefox team seems to have a track record of ignoring common sense and leaving these sorts of features in despite complaints, and because I know they'll just sweep complaints under the rug with some "blah blah it's for security purposes, so you don't get pushed/scammed!" reasoning, I'll ask: if you're not going to get rid of it like we want, can you at least put it ANYWHERE else on the screen except DIRECTLY OVER the video controls?? Just put it at the top instead.

lemonade311
New member

This is the MOST annoying feature from Firefox, every video I have to rewind cause it blocks subtitles

Also, if I misclick full screen or want to go back quickly I cannot because this dumb UI element blocks everything

Status changed to: In development
Jon
Community Manager
Community Manager

Hey all,

Good news...

This is being worked on — we'll share updates as they are ready. 

Thanks again for sharing feedback and helping push this work forward 🙌

Raxx
New member

Yes, please! Remove this thing. 🙏

64fanatic
Strollin' around

Is there any reason to make a toggle instead of outright removing this feature? The only group I can think of who mat want a toggle to enable it are possibly the blind (text to speech) but I don't know that myself.

LTFoReal
New member

I think having this on the first video full-screen makes sense but not every single time. I'm coming from ios where we can simply swipe the video out of full screen so it was nice to see the notification at first. But every time after that just blocks sub titles and gets annoying.

brixter
Making moves

The popup message is still there. For the longest time that I have used Firefox, I have never needed a message to teach me how to exit fullscreen mode. Why must I always be reminded of this every single time I fullscreen a video?