Yahoo comments not visible today

[ithinktfiam]

Today, on Yahoo news, the button to go to comments still exists, but I click on it and it goes to a blank space. User comments are not populated. It still works fine on Edge.

Any clue if this is a problem with a Firefox update or coming from Yahoo?

[ChrisM1]

The same thing is happening to me today.

[jscher2000 · Accepted solution]

Hi All, this could be a Tracking Protection block if Yahoo hosts its comments with a third party that does the same for multiple sites (the third party can engage in cross-site tracking). As a test, turn off Tracking Protection on Yahoo! News. Obviously not ideal because you'll probably see even more ads, but please test and see whether that allows comments to load. To do that, click the shield icon at the left end of the address bar (next to the lock) and click the slider switch to turn off tracking protection. Any difference?

[ChrisM1]

Yes, that worked. Thank you.

[jscher2000]

Thank you for testing that. You might be able to make a more precise exception just for the commenting site. This thread has an example of how people were setting that up for Disqus, but I don't know whether Yahoo uses Disqus:

https://old.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/1cs30e1/openweb_discussion_not_displaying_in_firefox/

[california90028]

tried your solution but it didn't work for me.  wish it had.

[california90028]

didn't work for me either.

[ithinktfiam]

Wait! That only worked once. However, on the page it wouldn't let me enter a comment, "failed to publish." When I closed the browser and opened a new one, it shows the shield with a line across it, indicating protection is off, but the comments only show up half the time and I still can't post.

Any additional things to try?

[jscher2000]

I looked at a new story, and the comments are in a frame on this URL:

https://openweb.jac.yahoosandbox.com/2.0.0/safeframe.html

If I click "Log in" it takes me to a Yahoo! login page. So it seems I can't test without diving in more deeply than I have time for at the moment.

[ithinktfiam]

I guess Yahoo changes how they managed the pages. Thanks for that solution.

[Sallyboy]

No comments loading for me

[cmoose]

I have this same problem on Safari. However, I have recently found a workaround. If I get a "View Comments" link with no number for the comments, when I click on it, it just disappears. However, I find that if I go to the right of the screen, there is an ad with an 'X'. If I click on the 'X', it goes back to the previous screen. Now if I click on that same story, it loads with the comments accessible.  

[ja7]

Hello jscher I don't find the shield. I am on a Macbook air using safari

[jscher2000]

---

@ja7 wrote:

Hello jscher I don't find the shield. I am on a Macbook air using safari

---

Normally it is just to the left of the lock icon. I can't think of a reason for it to be completely missing. Is it only missing on Yahoo?

[joedoksjr]

Thank you ... simple solution and clearly stated ... not a fan of Yahoo but comments show the heartbeat of its readers ... Any difference ... you betcha!

[Neil2024]

"click the shield icon at the left end of the address bar (next to the lock)". What? I do not see a "shield icon" at the left end of the address bar, or a "lock". All Yahoo comments disappear. Can you post a screen shot?

[Neil2024]

Hello Firefox and Mozilla. I am not a "new user" as you claim. Been using Firefox and Mozilla for years. I did upgrade to Windows 10 Pro, did that change throw you off? Firefox will not allow Yahoo comments to populate, when I click comments the entire section disappears. Please provide a fix. None of the fixes I read will work. Thank you.

[mtlhd1955]

Yeah. Yahoo keeps changing their format. When they go back to the old style pages, everything works fine. Now they've gone to this 'New Look' and the Comments sections don't show up again. 

[Luke1965]

Not sure what the problem is. It's only happening on my android tablet, not my android phone or my windows laptop. Things have been really weird this week, it's like AI has been given full control of everything and it's not doing that great a job.

[rugrat]

Yahoo not only rejects the majority of the comments I make,...now it's not even opening comment sections. I can't read comments. I can't help but feel like the Ai is trying to discourage my comments all together. I can post an lol with a gif and it gets rejected. Years ago I went to Xitter, formerly known as Twitter, because of Yahoo's comment section. Now Xitter sucks because of Elmo. Sucks when Ai tells you to sit down and STFU.

[mtntrainman]

Shut off the enhanced tracking shield'. It is to the left on the url line !! Yes...you will have to do that for every browser or tab you open !! Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.

FIX THIS BUG FIREFOX !!!

[Plato3356]

Interesting replies;however, I have attempted to correct the problem using most of the solutions provided without success. The question remains if this is surreptitious censorship by a third party moderator which has inherent political bias.