cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
ali1234
Making moves
Status: New idea

Web-based IDEs like Arduino and Github Codespaces are now commonplace. They are hobbled in Firefox due to an inability to access development boards without installing extra system software, which rather defeats the purpose of having an IDE that runs in your browser. This is not the case on Chrome, where Web USB and Web Serial can be used. (Clarification: they *could* be used on Chrome, but often are not because developers don't want to maintain two separate codebases.)

I will preempt the response I have received every previous time I brought up this topic: Web USB and Web Serial present no more of a security risk than web camera or location data, and Firefox already has a permissions system to protect those. On the other hand, the software you have to install to make Arduino IDE work in Firefox starts a webserver that shares your serial port over a websocket, just so that your browser can connect to it. It isn't clear if there are any protections at all on that websocket.

I will also note than the current prevalence of web-based development environments is in part due to Mozilla's insistence that everything should be able to run in the browser, along with projects like Firefox OS.

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_Serial_API

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/USB

107 Comments
gregstoll
Employee
Employee

@mhalano @Tyeth We don't have any updates on WebUSB right now - that spec is more complicated and we have some additional security concerns.

gregstoll
Employee
Employee

@griffi-gh @Tyeth Thanks for those examples! We have confirmed that some devices will work over Bluetooth, but we also know that Chrome does some additional things to make more devices work that we haven't implemented. There's more information at bug 2013908.