07-07-2026 06:41 AM
Who in the world decided that it was a good idea for "Open Firefox automatically when your computer starts up" to AUTOMATICALLY be checked for everyone? This is BAD. It is ANNOYING. I'm not sure exactly what version this happened (somewhere around 152?). PLEASE STOP THIS.
I am talking about setting up a new system (Windows), with a new/fresh install of Firefox, and now everyone that logs into the computer, whenever they start Firefox for the first time it AUTOMATICALLY chooses the option "Open Firefox automatically when your computer starts up". Those of us "in the know", know we can go into settings and disable it -- but WHY SHOULD WE HAVE TO DO THIS? I do not want programs just (sneakily) making the decision to start every time I login to my computer. And those that aren't quite as "tech savvy" don't know how to stop it. What a wonderful way to turn people off to Firefox!
Unsure if this is happening for existing users that get "updated", but most definitely for new installs.
PLEASE STOP THIS.
13-07-2026 12:27 PM
I second that! Extremely annoying... Turns out it even gets unable to deploy to hundreds of computers... When will it be fixed?
30-10-2026 05:57 AM
Not sure "it even gets unable to deploy to hundreds of computers" is the same issue?
If you're meaning deploying Firefox within an enterprise, that would be a separate topic.
29-10-2026 04:18 PM
Its also a security problem. If a user gets a drive by attack and trys to shutdown the computer to avoid the scam alert they get it again. Is Mozilla really seriously trying to decrease the level of security for everyone?
30-10-2026 05:56 AM
While Firefox would startup and load the same site again, by-default EXE files are not set to run after downloading. In about:preferences#downloads you can set some types of files to "Open in Firefox" or "Open in <name of an external app>", but not for EXE (or MSI) files.
So if a drive-by download occurred, a user would have to then choose to open or run the file that got downloaded; it wouldn't just be able to do so itself. And the moment the file is saved, your anti-virus should scan it anyway.
So I don't feel this is a huge risk. Maybe if Firefox at the time had a known security flaw that a website could exploit the moment it was opened then re-opening the same site may be more of an issue, but then going to any website during such a time could be a risk. Even major websites often pull Javascript from external sources, which could be altered to become malicious. Any use of the web comes with risk at all times!
The best ways to stay-safer would be: (1) don't install extensions you aren't sure about; (2) install the uBlock Origin extension, to prevent malicious ads and access to some known bad sites; and (3) change the DNS server in Firefox to a public one that blocks access to known bad sites.
30-10-2026 06:09 AM - edited 30-10-2026 06:15 AM
Hard disagree. Average users that get scam alert pop ups that they don't know how to close this is a security nightmare for.
The best security is when you don't set default options that take away the users control over the experience. Having the browser startup by default makes users less safe. Also there would be 0 reason for anyone to have the browser set this way.
30-10-2026 10:30 AM
I can agree that perhaps having Firefox by-default start itself when you log into Windows may not be a useful default, but I don't see the security angle.
When browsing the web, if a bad website opens, then close its tab or window. If it forces Firefox into full-screen that can be an issue (and is separately a dumb thing Firefox should not allow: sites should not be able to force the browser into full-screen), but I don't see how such sites showing again when you start your PC is a major-issue.
If users don't know how to close a tab or window, and the moment they see a scam site come up slam the power button on their PC off, then boot it back up and go "oh my god, it's come back again" then they need educating on what to do.
Such users are also unlikely to be using a safer DNS, or an extension like uBlock Origin, and so must be encountering scam-sites more-regularly than other users. So surely by now they've either learn how to deal with them, or a technically-minded friend or family member has helped mitigate the problem?
30-10-2026 10:48 AM - edited 30-10-2026 11:14 AM
If you hit a scam site that doesn't give you an option to close it and person uses the power button to resolve the issue, starting Firefox by default when windows loads complicates the problem. Education or not, this setting is not in the interest of the user.
Secondly Mozilla needs to give people a choice and not giving the user a choice is a security problem because it moves actions outside of the users zone of control. By configuring default settings that serves the interests of the business at the expense of the user, you are, in essence, creating a security risk when an attacker can use that an attack vector.
When people want browse, they launch the application themselves, not have it start arbitrarily when you start Windows.
Your argument sounds like what Apple said about butterfly keyboard design flaw, "you are just not using the keyboard correctly."
Gaslighting people into thinking that they are the problem is IMHO shortsighted. Make design choices that are in the interest and security of the user. If you can't do that, you don't belong in software development.
16-11-2026 04:24 AM
Fully agree. Patronizing users like this is what I'm used to from Microsoft – I chose Firefox precisely because I expected better.
With every new installation I now have to go looking for the autostart option and switch it off first. Many of us don't use our PCs only for browsing, so there's no reason the browser should be the first thing that launches when the computer starts.
And I'm not the only one: lots of people I know are annoyed by this setting as well.
Please respect the user's choice and turn this back into an opt-in feature.